Group Discussion about Soil and Earthworms

Resource for Grades K-4

Group Discussion about Soil and Earthworms

Media Type:
Video

Running Time: 1m 46s
Size: 5.2 MB

or


Source: WGBH Educational Foundation


Resource Produced by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Developed by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Funded by:


In this video segment from Teaching Elementary Life Science, teacher Jo Hannah Katz leads a group discussion with her second-grade students about their investigation of soil and earthworms. The students respond to her questions about the purpose of the investigation and the reasons soil and worms are important. Katz notes that group discussion encourages students to think about the questions she asks. She also says that it is more valuable to allow students to develop their own ideas and understanding than to receive knowledge from the teacher.

open Background Essay

Asking questions and making predictions and observations are the foundations of the scientific process, and all of these activities have a place in the K-4 classroom.

While building new knowledge on acquired knowledge is an obvious step in students’ development, instilling metacognitive practices are just as important. Students can make predictions based on prior knowledge, then later reflect on and review these predictions once the experiment has taken place.

Soil, composting and earthworms provide the context for Katz’s lesson, which models scientific inquiry. Katz sets up a hands-on inquiry by having students relate their questions about earthworm behavior. She asks her students to predict how the earthworms will behave during certain events, such as encounters with light or darkness. Katz asks her students to draw out their thinking and to make connections background knowledge, their predictions, their observations of the experiment, and even the students’ companion social studies coverage of Native Americans.

Through these methods, Kats helps her students integrate knowledge, achieve a heightened awareness of their inquiry, and lay the foundation for future reflection on their predictions. Students therefore gain metacognitive skills that supplement the knowledge they gather from the lesson.


open Discussion Questions

You may find it useful to watch this video with a group of your colleagues and then discuss it together.
  • To what extent is this discussion teacher-directed?
  • In what ways do these students build on each other’s ideas?
  • How might an elementary school teacher encourage students to respond more directly to each other’s thoughts? When is doing this desirable, and what problems might arise?
  • What experiences with group discussion in your classroom do you find effective with students? What experiences are challenging for you?

open Standards

 
to:

Loading Content Loading Standards

PBS LearningMedia
Teachers' Domain is moving to PBS LearningMedia on October 15, 2013. On that date you will be automatically redirected to PBS LearningMedia when visiting Teachers' Domain.
Close PBS LearningMedia PBS LearningMedia Login