More on Galileo's Big Mistake

Resource for Grades 6-12

WGBH: Nova
More on Galileo's Big Mistake

Media Type:
Document

Size: 144.7 KB


Source: NOVA: "Galileo's Battle for the Heavens"


Resource Produced by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Developed by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Credits

Collection Funded by:

National Science Foundation

Galileo sought and found empirical evidence for many prominent scientific theories of his time. Many of his discoveries and explanations are still cherished for their accuracy and elegance. Galileo's explanation for the ocean tides, however, isn't one of them. This essay from the NOVA Web site describes the observations and conclusions that came to be known as "Galileo's Big Mistake."

open Background Essay

A widely held view during Galileo's time connected movements of the Moon to the rise and fall of the tides. However, prior to Newtonian physics and recognition of the law of gravitation, which says that all objects are attracted to and by all other objects, an explanation for the Moon's effect on Earth's oceans was lacking.

Physicists now know that just as Earth's gravity pulls at the Moon, keeping it in orbit around our planet, the Moon also pulls at Earth. This pull causes ocean water to bulge on the side of Earth nearest the Moon. Surprisingly, it makes the water bulge on the other side of Earth at the same time. The simplest way to understand the two bulges is to realize that the Moon's gravitational pull is strongest on the water closest to the Moon, a bit weaker on the solid Earth and weaker still on the water on the far side of Earth. In essence, the Moon is both pulling the water that is closest to it away from Earth and pulling Earth away from the water on the far side.

Because Earth turns on its axis, making a full rotation every 24 hours, different points on Earth's surface are subject to these forces at different times. Nearest the Moon, ocean waters bulge and tides rise. As Earth's rotation continues away from the Moon's gravitational pull, tides recede, only to rise again about 12 hours later on the side of Earth, opposite the Moon. Because the Moon orbits Earth in the same direction as Earth spins on its axis (though much more slowly), each high and low tide arrives about 25 minutes later than the previous day's tides.

open Discussion Questions

  • What was Galileo's "big mistake"?
  • What everyday experience led Galileo to his explanation of the tides?
  • What actually causes the tides?
  • Do you think incorrect theories help or hinder the development of scientific ideas? Explain.
  • Can you think of another example of a scientific explanation that was reasonable given the tools and knowledge at the time but was later disproved by new evidence?
  • How did Galileo move the scientific process forward?

  • open Standards

     
    to:

    Loading Content Loading Standards

    National Science Digital Library Teachers' Domain is proud to be a Pathways portal to the National Science Digital Library.
    PBS LearningMedia
    Teachers' Domain is moving to PBS LearningMedia on October 15, 2013. On that date you will be automatically redirected to PBS LearningMedia when visiting Teachers' Domain.
    Close PBS LearningMedia PBS LearningMedia Login