A Partial History of My Stupidity, by Edward Hirsch

Resource for Grades 7-12

A Partial History of My Stupidity, by Edward Hirsch

Media Type:
Video

Running Time: 1m 29s
Size: 4.3 KB


Source: Poetry Everywhere

This media asset comes from Poetry Everywhere filmed at the Geraldine R. Dodge Poetry Festival.

Resource Produced by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Developed by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Credits

Collection Funded by:


This video segment from Poetry Everywhere features the poet Edward Hirsch reading his poem "A Partial History of My Stupidity" at the Dodge Poetry Festival. Edward Hirsch is drawn to writing about wandering alone in the night, when a person’s thoughts can’t be hidden or drowned out by daily activities, work, or other people’s words. Facing up to what is really on your mind is the exhilarating and scary result of  this night-time wandering.

For a biography of the poet Edward Hirsch please visit the Poetry Foundation Web site.

open Background Essay

“A Partial History of My Stupidity” is set at night. The narrator has “rushed out into the evening”, as he does “most nights,” and soon finds himself wrestling with his own thoughts and desires, the things he can avoid thinking about during the busy day.

Wandering at night is a theme of Hirsch’s: he has said he likes “the feeling that other people were asleep and you were a solo consciousness… a single voice, or a single writer under a lamp when everything else was dark …[it] loosened the mind for reverie, for a certain kind of dreamscape.”  In this poem, the speaker is concentrated on his solo consciousness, unaware of nature around him in the shape of birds and trees, aware only of the “tiger” within himself. As he walks alone, quiet and alone on the outside, inside he is taking stock of his “stupidity,” making an inventory of his feelings. A poem can be a way of exploring yourself, having an inner monologue.

He does not know what he really wants, or what he should want, or how to justify his own wants and needs in the face of other people’s demands or suffering. He “carries a cage around inside me.” He doesn’t give up on emotion, and caring about other people, but he also can’t lose his own self-consciousness: other people suffer and he does nothing.

Read a biography of the poet Edward Hirsch at the Poetry Foundation Web site.


open Discussion Questions

  • The first stanza sets up the narrator as stuck in traffic for hours, long after night falls. Is the rest of the poem a flashback to walking at night, a meditation on walking at night, or something else? Is nighttime more conducive to thinking? Why does the poet start with an everyday occurrence?
  • What do you think is “the wildness within” that the narrator fears, that prevents him from acting on his thoughts?
  • Why did the poet include the situation mentioned in stanza 7? What is going on in the world today that might be parallel to this situation?
  • The poet mentions Stoics, a group of philosophers characterized by an indifference to suffering and passion. Would they have written poetry?
  • Are there dream-like qualities in this poem?

open Standards

 
to:

Loading Content Loading Standards

PBS LearningMedia
Teachers' Domain is moving to PBS LearningMedia on October 15, 2013. On that date you will be automatically redirected to PBS LearningMedia when visiting Teachers' Domain.
Close PBS LearningMedia PBS LearningMedia Login