Questioning Jewish Identity

Resource for Grades 10-12

Questioning Jewish Identity

Media Type:
Video

Running Time: 2m 39s
Size: 14.9 MB


Source: Finding Your Roots: "Rick Warren, Angela Buchdahl, and Yasir Qadhi"

Learn more about Finding Your Roots.

Resource Produced by:

WNET

Collection Developed by:

WNET

Collection Credits

Collection Funded by:

Corporation for Public Broadcasting Coca-Cola
Corporate funding is provided by The Coca-Cola Company, Johnson & Johnson, McDonald’s and American Express. Additional funding is provided by the Carnegie Corporation of New York, The Atlantic Philanthropies, Ford Foundation and the Pew Charitable Trusts. Support is also provided by The Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB) and PBS.

In this video segment from the PBS series Finding Your Roots, Rabbi Angela Buchdahl discusses her experiences growing up and details encounters that caused her to question her Jewish identity. Buchdahl explains she struggled with her religion because people doubted her faith for superficial reasons (for example, she did not “look” Jewish and she did not have a “Jewish name”). In the end, Buchdahl’s questioning led to her decision to become a rabbi.

open Discussion Questions

  • In the video, Angela Buchdahl discusses how she questioned her Jewish identity as a young person. What made Buchdahl begin to question her identity?
  • According to the video, what stereotypes did Angela Buchdahl encounter? How did they affect her?
  • Based on the video segment, how did Buchdahl resolve her questions about her identity?

  • open Transcript

    NARRATION: Rabbi Angela Buchdahl serves as cantor at New York's prestigious Central Synagogue-she is the first Asian American to be invested as a cantor and the first Asian American to be ordained as a Rabbi in all of North America.

    Angela was born in Seoul, South Korea on July 8th 1972 to a Jewish American army veteran and a Korean Buddhist mother. Angela told me that as she grew up in Tacoma, Washington, where they moved when she was five, she often felt conflicted about her identities as an American, a Korean, and a Jew.

    Though raised in the Jewish religion, it was during a trip to Israel as a teenager when she was forced to confront the "authenticity" of her religious beliefs. How could a person who looked like her, someone demanded, be genuinely Jewish?

    RABBI ANGELA BUCHDAHL: I felt so rejected by the larger Jewish community. I’d had a lot of people say to me, you’re not really Jewish. I remember I called my mother from Israel. I couldn’t even speak for the first few minutes because I was just weeping so hard. And I said, “That’s it, I think I’m going to just not be Jewish anymore. I’m going to stop.” I don’t have a Jewish name. Look at me, I don’t have a Jewish face. I could just stop being Jewish and nobody would ever know. And my mother said, “Is that really possible?” And I realized I couldn’t shed my Jewish identity any more than I could shed being a woman or being Korean. It might not be as evident on my face but it was, not just a part of my DNA, but it was the way I looked at the whole world. It was…it was who I was.

    HENRY LOUIS GATES, JR.: Hmmm.

    BUCHDAHL: In, in every fiber of my being. I came back from that summer and I said, “I want to be a rabbi.”

    NARRATION: Last year, Angela made "Newsweek's" list of the 50 most influential Rabbis in America, and she is one of the rising stars in the Reform Movement.


    open Standards

     
    to:

    Loading Content Loading Standards

    PBS LearningMedia
    Teachers' Domain is moving to PBS LearningMedia on October 15, 2013. On that date you will be automatically redirected to PBS LearningMedia when visiting Teachers' Domain.
    Close PBS LearningMedia PBS LearningMedia Login