Haiti: The Aid Dilemma

Resource for Grades 10-12

WGBH: Frontline
Haiti: The Aid Dilemma

Media Type:
Video

Running Time: 14m 49s
Size: 6.3 MB


Source:

FRONTLINE Haiti: The Aid Dilemma

For more resources from this report go to FRONTLINE Haiti: The Aid Dilemma.


Resource Produced by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Developed by:

WGBH Educational Foundation

Collection Funded by:

The John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Park Foundation

In the aftermath of the devastating earthquake in Haiti, post-disaster relief is creating a new kind of problem for businesses there. The massive influx of food aid has altered the price of rice, throwing the delicate balance in Haiti's food supply chain out of whack and threatening to collapse the country's rice market.

In this video, NPR’s Planet Money reporter Adam Davidson examines Haiti’s fragile economic system, and methods of delivering relief that they hope will help with long-term recovery efforts.

Supplemental Media Available:

Haiti: The Aid Dilemma Teacher's Guide (Document)

open Background Essay

Haiti: The Aid Dilemma is the third in a series of ongoing FRONTLINE reports on Haiti with correspondent Adam Davidson of NPR’s Planet Money

In the aftermath of the devastating earthquake in Haiti, post-disaster relief is creating a new kind of problem for businesses there. The massive influx of food aid has altered the price of rice, throwing the delicate balance in Haiti's food supply chain out of whack and threatening to collapse the country's rice market. It's the kind of problem that can turn a one-time disaster into a crisis that lasts years. But international aid organizations like the U.N.'s World Food Programme are trying out a new method of delivering relief that they hope will avoid that problem.

"It's a simple idea," says reporter Davidson. "If people are hungry, don't give them rice. Give them money to buy rice, or vouchers that amount to the same thing. That way, instead of destroying local business, you strengthen it."

Video Segment Themes:

  • The massive influx of food aid in Haiti after the earthquake altered the price of rice, making it difficult for wholesale rice distributors like Melissa to stock her store shelves affordably.
  • Since the quake, it is difficult for Haitians to earn money, which decreases demand for rice.
  • Such supply-and-demand disruptions in the local economy can turn a one-time disaster like the earthquake into a crisis that lasts for years.
  • To avoid destabilizing the local economy, international aid organizations are testing the idea of giving people money or vouchers to buy rice, rather than providing the commodity itself.

open Discussion Questions

Classroom Discussion Questions:

  • Describe the relationships among the following levels of the Haitian rice economy: street vendors, micro-wholesalers, large wholesalers and foreign suppliers. How did the earthquake disrupt these relationships?
  • Explain both positive and negative effects of humanitarian relief efforts on supply and demand for rice in Haiti.
  • Consider the decisions made at the port of Port-au-Prince by the U.S. military and the World Food Programme regarding what products will be allowed to unload with limited docking space. Evaluate the pros and cons of allowing the following supplies to be unloaded: humanitarian aid (food, medical supplies); military supplies (building material, gasoline); or commercial products (products for sale).
  • How can the international community best support Haiti’s short-term needs after the quake without undermining the country’s long-term recovery?
  • What role should the Haitian government play in the country’s recovery?
  • What lessons from Haiti can be applied to future disaster relief efforts?

    Go Further: Featured Lesson Plan from FRONTLINE Teacher's Center


open Standards

 
to:

Loading Content Loading Standards

PBS LearningMedia
Teachers' Domain is moving to PBS LearningMedia on October 15, 2013. On that date you will be automatically redirected to PBS LearningMedia when visiting Teachers' Domain.
Close PBS LearningMedia PBS LearningMedia Login